Scaling People, Not Just Revenue: The Hidden Lever for Sustainable Growth in Insurance Brokerages

In the independent insurance brokerage world, growth is often treated as the endgame. Agencies and brokerages celebrate doubling revenue, expanding into new geographies, and onboarding fresh producers. But behind every leap forward is a fundamental truth that often goes unspoken: a firm’s ability to grow is only as strong as its ability to scale its people.

At DOXA, we’ve had a front-row seat to the growth stories of high-performing firms across the country. We’ve also seen what happens when production outpaces planning—when high sales velocity stretches teams to the breaking point and long-term value is sacrificed for short-term wins. For broker-owners preparing for a liquidity event or considering M&A options, understanding the critical link between workforce planning and sales velocity isn’t just operational wisdom—it’s enterprise value 101.

The Sales Velocity Trap

Let’s start with the basics. Most insurance executives are familiar with sales velocity as a pipeline metric—how quickly opportunities move from quote to close. But that view is incomplete. A more useful metric for scaling independent firms looks like this:

Sales Velocity = Organic New Commission ÷ Core Book Size

This isolates earned organic growth from fee-based, transactional, or non-core income. Why does that matter? Because the higher the sales velocity, the faster new clients, policies, and service expectations are landing on your team’s plate. And if the internal structure can’t handle the pace, the business will feel it—first in producer burnout, then in rising E&O exposure, declining retention, and eventually, in your valuation.

Sales velocity is the gas pedal. Workforce planning is the transmission. If you slam on the gas without upgrading the transmission, it’s only a matter of time before the system breaks down.

The Hidden Cost of Doubling

Let’s say your agency is growing fast—organically doubling every five years. That means ~15% annual growth. It sounds manageable… until you translate that into real staffing needs:

👔 Producers

To hit $1.5M in new business, you need 7–10 productive producers averaging $150K–$215K in new commission. But you can’t just hire them—you have to enable them. That means CRM, marketing automation, and quoting tools that actually reduce administrative drag.

📋 Account Managers

A seasoned AM can manage roughly $500K–$700K in commercial or $400K–$600K in personal lines commission. Doubling your book without doubling your AM capacity? That’s a recipe for error-prone service and client attrition unless you implement serious tech or tiered service models.

📈 Marketing & Processing

As quoting activity scales, so does the burden on your marketing and processing teams. Inaccurate submissions or slow turnaround times silently erode both producer trust and carrier relationships—two cornerstones of a thriving brokerage.

🛠 Admin, Ops & Compliance

Rule of thumb: for every $1M–$2M in revenue, one additional operations or admin role is needed to maintain workflows and compliance. These are the glue roles, often undervalued until a renewal deadline is missed or a system outage exposes a single point of failure.

🧑‍💼 Leadership

As you grow, command-and-control structures fall apart. One VP or principal overseeing every service or sales person doesn’t scale. You’ll need player-coaches—team leads who can manage 5–6 direct reports, maintain quality, and mentor talent.

Planning for Growth Instead of Reacting to It

Most firms wait too long to hire. The result? Employees operate in survival mode. Clients notice delays. Producers complain about service bottlenecks. Top talent burns out—or walks. That’s not a growth plan. It’s a slow-motion stall-out.

The alternative is a capacity-based staffing model that links hiring to growth milestones. Benchmark each role: how many clients, policies, and commission dollars can one AM or producer support in your firm’s model? Start planning hires before those thresholds are crossed.

And don’t just track lagging indicators like revenue per employee—look for leading signals of stress:

• Longer quote turnaround times

• Increased service errors or endorsements backlogs

• Slower onboarding of new clients

• Higher complaint volume from producers or clients

These are early red flags of capacity strain and talent misalignment. Treat them as predictive KPIs, not hindsight lessons.

Build from Within—It’s More Scalable Than You Think

Hiring is only part of the answer. Internal talent development is your hidden growth engine. Promote CSRs to AMs. Mentor junior producers. Invest in leadership training. Create clear, structured pathways for advancement so your team scales with the business.

Remember, external hiring can’t keep pace with growth forever. The firms that succeed through M&A aren’t just those with high revenue—they’re the ones with low turnover, strong bench strength, and resilient teams.

The DOXA Lens: Why Workforce Planning Matters in M&A

In M&A conversations, especially with firms looking for strong long-term partners, buyers look well beyond top-line growth. They want to know:

• Can your team sustain the momentum?

• Are your service ratios efficient—or stretched?

• Do you have repeatable systems and a scalable org chart?

When a firm shows not just strong production, but strategic workforce alignment, it sends a powerful message: “We’re not just growing fast—we’re growing right.”

For sellers, this translates into stronger multiples and better cultural fit with acquirers. For buyers, it reduces integration risk and signals that leadership has their eye on long-term value—not just short-term wins.

A Final Word to Independent Leaders

The temptation to focus on new business is understandable. It’s exciting, measurable, and often the metric boards and partners push hardest. But if you don’t simultaneously build the foundation to support that growth, the cracks will show.

Great insurance businesses aren’t just built on books—they’re built on people. And the smartest ones plan for scale early, not after they’ve hit the ceiling.

At DOXA, we help firms scale with intention, not just ambition. If you’re navigating growth or preparing for a future transaction, let’s talk. We’re not just looking for firms—we’re looking for partners who want to scale their people as well as their profits.

Let’s connect.
Ready to talk workforce strategy, growth readiness, or your firm’s future? DOXA can help.

📩 Reach out at doxa.com/contact

#MGA #insurancegrowth #workforceplanning #insuranceM&A #scaleyourpeople #leadership #agencyowners #independentagents